In Charlotte Brontë’s Villette, the development of female intellect is portrayed as being in conflict with emotional fulfillment. This study argues that nineteenth-century girls’ education, characterized by surveillance and the suppression of desire, acts as a restrictive emotional architecture that dismantles Lucy Snowe’s capacity for romantic agency. While Lucy gains an early understanding of passion from Miss Marchmont, her transition to the pensionnat in Villette subjects her to Madame Beck’s pervasive surveillance, which imposes the preservation of innocence through the quenching of sexual desire. Central to this analysis is the garden as a site of internalized repression. Lucy’s act of sealing Dr. John’s letters in a bottle and burying them beneath a pear tree—a space haunted by a nun buried alive for breaking vows of celibacy—symbolizes the literal entombment of her feelings. This research contends that such educational conditioning fosters a persistent hesitancy that also stifles her later connection with M. Paul Emanuel. Her inability to overcome this learned reservedness in the pleasure garden not only prevents a deeper human bond but denies her the agency to avert the tragic fate of their relationship. The shipwreck of the Paul et Virginie stands as a final indictment of an educational system that sacrifices female autonomy at the altar of Victorian Innocence. Ultimately, this paper illustrates how institutionalized constraints curtailed individual growth, providing new insight into the ways social structures governed the intersection of intelligence and intimacy in nineteenth-century literature.

Authors:
Chia-Wei Hu, National Chengchi University, Taiwan

About the Presenter(s)
Chia-Wei Hu is a PhD student in the Department of English at National Chengchi University. She is interested in novel study, with a particular focus on the intersection of spatiality and subjectivity.

See this presentation on the full schedule – Saturday Schedule

Bookmark