The mixed constitution—a system combining monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy in balanced proportions—was conceived to prevent their degeneration into the corresponding vicious forms of tyranny, oligarchy, and ochlocracy. Central to the political thought of classical antiquity, it explained long term stability through the equilibrium of rule by one, by the few, and by the many. This study reactivates, and elaborates on, the classical paradigm as a theoretical framework for analysing the hybrid composition of modern democracies. Methodologically, the research is grounded in a neo institutionalist and historical comparative perspective, employing an idiographic and multidisciplinary approach that integrates conceptual interpretation with empirical illustration. Examples are drawn mainly from the ancient Roman Republic and three modern democracies—the USA, France, and Israel—chosen for their different institutional structures and political cultures. The analysis identifies distinctive combinations of “monarchical” leaders, “aristocratic” elites, and “democratic” participation, tracing their respective weight and interaction with their corrupt counterparts: executive dominance (at times despotic), oligarchic entrenchment, and populist volatility. Theoretically, the study moves beyond the orthodox, quantitative taxonomy of classical thought to include governing elements derived from other political types—such as plutocracy, theocracy, technocracy, and ethnocracy—defined by the principles through which power is legitimised and exercised. By extending and refining the ancient framework through modern sociological insights, the research develops a renewed analytical model of the mixed constitution, capable of applying not only to polities but also to other forms of organisation, including municipal government, political parties, and academic administration.

Authors:
Ephraim David, University of Haifa, Israel

About the Presenter(s)
Ephraim David Professor (emeritus) of History, the Department of General History, University of Haifa. Research interests are focused on ancient Greek history, with a special emphasis on Sparta and on the Athenian democracy: social and political history, history of ideas, mentalities, semiotics of communication and anthropology. My current project is a book on Sparta's impact on political theory. General interests include literature and the world of Italian opera.

See this presentation on the full schedule – Saturday Schedule

Bookmark